Cragmama "Not all who wander are lost…" JRR Tolkien

Why the Second Baby is Easier…and Harder

From the moment we told the world we were pregnant again, it seemed that everyone that had been there, done that more than once, felt obligated to express their opinions.  It seemed like everyone clearly fell into one of two camps – the “Number 2 will be a breeze compared to Number 1” folks, and the “Number 2 makes life really complicated” people.  With such a wide range of (unsolicited) experiences to take in, we really didn’t know what to expect.  (And considering that our number 2 is not even a month old yet, we hardly qualify as experts when it comes to family expansion projects…and I’m about to share my unsolicited opinion like everyone else lol)  While I can’t choose a side quite yet, I can definitively say that I can see where both sides are coming from…and that so far I’m leaning towards the “easier” side of the spectrum!


Here’s been our experience so far when it comes to comparing life as a family of 3 vs family of 4.

Getting back into the groove is way easier the second time around!

Getting back into the groove is way easier the second time around!


1.  Labor and Delivery – To be frank, a birth canal that has already had one passenger generally has an easier time with subsequent ones.  But even if your labor isn’t shorter or physically easier, you will for sure be more mentally prepared for what’s about to happen.  

2. Breastfeeding – The second time around, only one of you needs to learn how to do this.  All that prior knowledge and experience goes a long way in alleviating common first time around fears about having enough milk, nursing too much/too little, and being able to gauge what is “normal” for your little one.  

3.  Mom (and Dad) Know What They’re Doing – It’s not that Baby #2 creates a laissez-faire attitude, but everything is just a lot more relaxed because you have some idea of what to expect.  You can also reassure yourself that your parental instinct got you through one newborn stage successfully, so there’s no reason to think it won’t happen again.  For example, as a first time mom I spent the majority of my nightly nursing marathons googling everything I possibly could about every weird sound my son made in his sleep, since he sounded like a dinosaur on his death bed.  Eventually I learned that newborns are just noisy sleepers…this time around I put down my phone and spend that time sleeping…

4.  You Can See the Big Picture – While adding a helpless little person who only knows how to eat, sleep, cry, and poop is never an easy transition, the second time around comes with a long-term perspective.  Yes, some days may be long, but experience tells you that the weeks, months, and before you know it, years, fly by at the speed of light.  Knowing that the majority of your frustrations are just a phase makes it easier to smile (and maybe even laugh!) through those inevitable crying jags and sleepless nights.

...but sharing means growing pains.

…but sharing means growing pains.

Why it’s HARDER
1.  Older Sibling – 
Yeah so the reason for that newfound newborn confidence from number 3 is back at your house waiting for you…rather impatiently by the way.  No matter how well you try to prepare your older child, there’s no way they will be able to comprehend how much there world will be forever changed…but all of a sudden there’s a new little intruder that is suddenly usurping all of Mommy and Daddy’s time.  Instead of 1 on 1 (or 2 on 1 when Dad was home), a second time mom quickly finds herself outnumbered (and possibly overwhelmed.)  Thankfully this particular one got easier and easier with each passing day, as we figured out new and creative ways to get the one on one time that we all needed.  

2.  You Can’t Sleep When the Baby Sleeps – That seems to be the number one catch-phrase when it comes to new mom advice.  And for good reason – it’s great advice!  But while it generally works out great for first time moms, a mother with another child quickly realizes that it’s just not practical.  

3.  Life Can’t Revolve Around Naps and Feedings – With the first kid, it’s (comparatively) easy to be flexible and get things done in between sleepy time and feeding time.  But with double the kiddos makes things a lot more  complicated.  Rest assured that your baby will demand to nurse as soon as you are ready to load up the car to take your older kiddo to preschool (or not be finished yet, if you tried a preemptive approach.)  And it  goes without saying that all morning preschool programs end just before, after, or smack dab in the middle of the anticipated longest nap of the day.  

4.  Divide and Conquer – With one baby, taking shifts with the other parent was easy – and the subsequent alone time was glorious.  But trading out kid duty for BOTH at once is a lot more difficult to manage, especially at first.  The concept of taking shifts now translates to “You take the big one and I’ll take the little one.”  Those glorious alone-time moments are fleeting at best. 


As far as the easier/harder debate, the bottom line is that parenting is hard work, regardless of whether you have one child or ten. The first child may have received more of my undivided attention, but the second child gets to reap all the benefits of my prior experience as a mother.  That being said, I probably have had less entirely overwhelming days this time around so far (though there certainly have been a few!)  But again, this is just my personal opinion (after only a month with 2!)  I would love to know everyone else’s thoughts on the matter, so please weigh in!  (And if you’ve got more than 2, I’d love to hear that perspective as well!)  



8 Responses to “Why the Second Baby is Easier…and Harder”

  1. betsy

    love this!!! 🙂 I think I took notes, ha ha… thanks for sharing!


  2. Heather

    Perfect description! The hardest part with #2 is indeed not having the luxury of sleeping when they do because there is #1 needed one-on-one time. When you add #3, the first two can entertain each other which helps….but not with naps for mom:( It also means parents are outnumbered! #3 basically grows up in the car (praise God we had a drive-in basement garage!) while you tote and fetch the others…but absolutely worth all of it!


  3. Kelsey

    Your posts are very applicable to me right now. I’m definitely worried about adding a second child. I’m actually more nervous about this baby than I was with my first. Being outnumbered is a little intimidating! I’m glad to hear you’re finding the experience leaning towards being easier rather than harder.


  4. Well, I don’t know if I should post this on the internet or not, but I thought maybe other people would have similar thoughts. I had pretty terrible PPD after my first, and I know it was exacerbated by lack of sleep. I am one of those people who gets physically and mentally ill if I don’t sleep enough. And this is probably the #1 reason that I don’t want a baby #2. If I actually got LESS sleep with this one… bad, bad, bad.

    You however, do not look like you are having any troubles! Way to go Crag Mama!!


  5. Erica

    Betsy and Kelsey – glad you enjoyed the post : )

    Heather – thanks for chiming in. Interesting dynamic about the first two entertaining each other when baby #3 comes along, hadn’t thought about that, but it makes sense! I think a lot of the harder/easier opinions depends on the spacing of your kiddos, and their temperaments at those ages.

    Kate – Wanna know our secret? This time around we got a baby that sleeps lol. My first was pretty, shall we say, high maintenance? This baby is a breeze comparatively! Not that she never cries or anything (we are hardcore clusterfeeding during every evening fussy time like clockwork!), but she actually sleeps for more than 45 minutes at a time, unlike my son. Glad that this is the order they came in, otherwise we would have been thinking the easier baby was all due to our “superior parenting skills.” We’re not doing anything that different this time around, it’s just all those things that everyone said would work with my first (but didn’t), DO work with this one! So far anyway…:)


  6. Erica

    Oh, and Kate, I don’t think you should bat an eye about talking about PPD on the internet. Good on you for feeling comfortable to share a piece of your journey 🙂


  7. We’re about to step on the same path – our boy is 26 months and our girl is arriving in the next week or two. So thanks for sharing!


  8. SO true 🙂 And while #2 rocked my world, #3 is actually proving to be easier too…crazy busy, but it’s nice to have this parenting thing (sort of) figured out. For now. 😉 You have a beautiful family!


Leave a Comment Life is in the conversation.


Your email will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

“Not all who wander are lost.” —JRR TOLKIEN